The Book of Tobit

Catholicism is experiencing a resurgence, these days.

The President and the Pope are trading critiques of each other’s words and works through the media in the wake of American military activity in the Middle East — though that’s very of-the-moment. More than the headlines in the news from the last few weeks, though, I’ve been noticing a groundswell in Catholic involvement and devotion among the students of Kent State University. Many students in H2O Church circles, even, want to talk about Catholicism (and Eastern Orthodoxy) in ways that I haven’t seen in all my twenty-seven years of leading churches with a focus on the next generation of young adults.

At Youngstown State University, it’s more than a resurgence; it’s a way of life for many people who have grown up in the Mahoning Valley. I don’t understand exactly why or how the Catholic presence is so strong in this area, but I’ve observed it since first starting to visit YSU and talk to students and pray about a church plant (starting in 2016, with a church plant happening in 2022). Ethnic identity seems to be a part of it — with exceptionally strong Italian, Polish, Slovak, Irish, and Hungarian communities in the Youngstown area (many of which have historic ties to the Roman Catholic Church). Maybe the area’s working-class ethos is a part of it, too. In any event, my involvement with H2O YSU this school year has included even more conversations about Catholicism than what I’ve experienced in Kent. And I’ve been thankful for this.

I grew up with a pretty deep distrust of Catholicism. It was inferred that we (Baptists) had “real” faith that fostered a personal connection with Jesus, while they (Catholics) had a nominal, or cultural, sense of religious obligation that fostered shallow spirituality and lots of going-through-the-motions. In retrospect, it seems like there was some ethnic tribalism at play there, too. When I moved to the Netherlands (in 2003) and started getting to know the wider Christian community in Amsterdam — and even in traditionally-Catholic places like Nijmegen — I started to see Catholics as allies rather than enemies, particularly in light of the increasingly secular, Post-Christian landscape in Europe. I had a really meaningful spiritual retreat at a Benedictine monastery called Benedictusberg in 2011, and it got me thinking even more about the beauty (albeit mixed with imperfection) of Catholic spirituality. I built on that experience with another spiritual retreat to a different Benedictine monastery called the Monastery of Christ in the Desert in 2023. I’ve had other experiences more recently, too.

All that to say that my heart has been softened towards Catholicism. I don’t know how all this might have gone over with my grandfather, the Reverend George L. Asp (there’s some reason to expect that he might be rolling in his grave as I type these words). But I think I can meaningfully honor the legacy of my family’s faith traditions while also honoring the faith traditions of others (especially within the Christian faith).

Anyway, a recent discussion with our Maag Monday Life Group at Youngstown State University got me thinking that maybe it would be interesting and/or instructive to read at least one of the books that appear in Catholic Bibles but not in Protestant Bibles. Some call these books the Apocrypha. Some call them Deuterocanonical Books. Anyway, I decided to read the Book of Tobit (mostly because it’s usually listed first among these books). And now that I’ve finished this reading, I thought I would take some notes for my own benefit — and perhaps for the benefit of others, too.

Synopsis

The Book of Tobit is named for a man who was exiled to Nineveh during the time when the Assyrian Empire dominated much of the Middle East (there’s a reference to the prophet Nahum in the last chapter of Tobit, which might be helpful for dating things — but I wasn’t too concerned with the metadata for this read-through). Tobit describes himself as a devout Jew who is especially concerned with generosity and courage. His wife’s name is Anna, and they have a young-adult son named Tobias (or Tobiah, in some translations). In the second chapter, the family experiences hardship when Tobit’s eyes are afflicted by a strange infection that leads to total blindness. Tobit and Anna start to argue with each other, and Tobit laments before the Lord.

The third chapter of Tobit explains the way that on the same day of Tobit’s lamentation, a young woman named Sarah also started lamenting her own hardships in a different city — specifically related to a demon that caused the deaths of seven young men to whom she had been betrothed. Both prayers were answered with the heavenly commissioning of an angel named Raphael (who also seems to go by the name of Azariah).

In the fourth chapter of the book, Tobias is commissioned to travel away from Nineveh to collect some of his family’s wealth and to find a wife for himself (who turns out to be Sarah). Raphael joins up with Tobias on his journey (chapter five), and Tobias has a strange encounter with a large fish on the banks of the Tigris River (chapter six). Raphael tells Tobias to harvest the fish’s gall, heart, and liver to shortly be used as medicines together with prayer in delivering both Tobit and Sarah from their afflictions: “When you enter the bridal chamber, take some of the heart and liver of the fish and place them on the burning incense. When the demon smells the odor that will arise, he will flee, and never again will he be seen near her” (Tobit 6:17-18). The plan is enacted in chapters seven and eight, and then in chapter nine Tobias succeeds in securing his family wealth, as well. In chapters ten and eleven, Tobias and Sarah return to the home of Tobit and Anna, and they use the gall of the fish to heal Tobit’s eyes.

Raphael reveals his supernatural status in chapter twelve, and Tobit prays, rejoices, and prophesies in the last two chapters of the book before his death. After Anna dies and is buried next to Tobit, Tobias and Sarah return to her family — and they all live, basically, happily ever after.

Almsgiving

There were a few distinctive elements of the Book of Tobit that stood out to me, in comparison and contrast to other parts of the Christian Scriptures. One of the most notable themes in the Book of Tobit is the giving of alms, or financial assistance for the poor. It’s spelled out in the first chapter of Tobit as a “third tithe,” drawn from Tobit’s income after the first tenth was set aside for sacrifices in the temple in Jerusalem and the second tenth was used to double down on the temple contribution. Finances are mentioned in half of the chapters in the book. The most complete treatment of almsgiving might be in Tobit 4:7-11, where Tobit tells Tobias, “Distribute alms from your possessions. If you do not avert your gaze from anyone who is poor, God will never turn his face away from you. Your almsgiving should be in proportion to your means. If you have been blessed with great abundance, give much; if you possess little, do not be afraid to give even some of that. In this way you will be accumulating for yourself a goodly treasure for the day of adversity. For almsgiving delivers the donor from death and saves people from descending into darkness. Those who give alms have a worthy offering in the presence of the Most High.”

And honestly, I can’t find anything objectionable in this emphasis! Many other parts of the Christian Scriptures clearly emphasize the dangers of materialism (like in Matthew 6:19-24, Hebrews 13:5, and Ecclesiastes 5:10-11) and the benefits of generous and intentional care for the poor (like in Matthew 25:31-46, Galatians 2:9-10, and James 2:1-16). I’ve noticed that those among the Catholic branch of the Christian family tree are often more concerned with social justice than other branches of the Christian family tree, and it seems reasonable to me that their inclusion of the Book of Tobit within their canon may be at least a part of why that is so.

Guardian Angels

There’s an angelic figure in the Book of Tobit who goes by the name of Raphael and/or Azariah. It seems like most of the humans in the story view him as a human, but some also seem to have a sense that he is an angel. In any event, Raphael’s original commissioning was related to Tobit and Sarah — but he primarily acts as a sort of guardian angel for Tobias throughout the narrative. He agrees to accompany Tobias on his journey for the express purpose of providing protection and guidance through unfamiliar territory. He instructs Tobias how to capture the large fish and harvest its vital organs, and he then provides further instruction for how those vital organs (plus prayer) can be used to provide protection from demons. And he only reveals his angelic status to Tobias and Tobit at the end of the journey, when everything is set to right.

There aren’t many other sections of the Christian Scriptures (at least as far as I know) that speak so suggestively of personalized guardian angels, though such figures have become a part of popular culture (even among the irreligious). Lot’s escape from Sodom and Gomorrah, recorded in Genesis 19:1-29 is the closest comparison I can think of. The angels visiting Zechariah and Mary in the first chapter of the Gospel of Luke might be another point of consideration, though I’d suggest that they seem more like heralds, or messengers, than guardians in this instance. In any event, it’s interesting to see that the Book of Tobit provides a precedent for why some Christians ascribe to the idea of guardian angels more than others.

Healing Powers of Sacred Elements

This is the part of the Book of Tobit that felt the most unusual to me, on my first reading. The fish guts. In Tobit 6:7-9, it’s explained like this: “Then the youth posed this question to the angel: ‘Brother Azariah, what medicinal value can there be in the heart, liver, and gall of the fish?’ He replied, ‘As far as the heart and liver are concerned, when you burn them and the smoke rises in the presence of someone, man or woman, who is afflicted by a demon or an evil spirit, that affliction will disappear for good and will never plague that person again. As regards the gall, if you anoint the eyes of someone where white patches have appeared on them and then blow on those patches, the eyes will be healed.'” And indeed, it’s this special fish that provides everything that’s needed to solve the problems of Tobit, Sarah, and Tobias. Perhaps it’s important to note that the “medicine” was combined with prayer, at least when it came to driving away the demons.

The closest comparison that came to my mind from other parts of the Christian Scriptures was the moment recorded in Exodus 4:24-26 where Zipporah (the wife of Moses) performed an emergency circumcision in an unusual, midnight confrontation with the Lord. Maybe also a bit like when Elisha sprinkled flour (or salt, depending on the translation) into a pot of stew that was feared to be poisonous (see 2 Kings 4:38-44). It’s just the weirdest parts of the Bible, magnified and made into a larger part of the story. To me it feels a bit like magic, in a way that’s suspicious. At the same time, the healing powers of sacred elements in the Book of Tobit help me to better understand the practices I’ve observed within Catholicism for lighting special candles… hanging the crucifix in special places… wearing special symbols around one’s neck… using holy water as a cleansing ritual… And that wider context is helpful, in any event.

Conclusion

I’m glad I took some time to give the Book of Tobit a read. I’m not ready to call it “canon,” but I’m also not ready to call it “quits” with these books that appear in the Catholic Bible but not in the Protestant Bible. I’ll probably try another one some other time, but I’ll likely continue to view it as an exercise in cultural anthropology more than an act of religious devotion. Even so, I’d say my heart is continuing to soften towards other branches of the Christian family tree, and I’d say that’s a good thing.

This entry was posted in Church, Culture, H2O Kent, Reading, Recommendations, Recommended Reading, Small Groups, The Bible, The United States of America, Traditions. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *